Follow Josh on Google+ Follow J0shTucker on Twitter

The Problem of Evil is a philosophical question that goes something like this:

If God is omnibenevolent (fully good), omnipotent (all powerful) and omniscient (all knowing), why does evil exist?

Put differently, the problem asks how a good God, fully aware of every evil and fully capable of preventing it, could allow evil to exist.

To answer this question, philosophers and theologians have taken a variety of approaches, leading to a field of study known as theodicy, which specifically attempts to explain and/or prove how a God with these three qualities can coexist with a world rife with evil. However, in thinking about it, I can’t help wondering if we’re not getting ahead of ourselves by posing the question in this way.

Read the rest…

September 22, 2011 · 4 comments

In late 2006, I left the church, disillusioned with the self-centered nature of the Christian experience and the church’s near inability to reach out to those beyond its own walls. For a brief period, I was part of a local iteration of the Emergent Church movement, though that was short lived, as the group I was a part of were interested in a kind of faith experience that did not appeal to me.

Around the same time, something happened that raised in my mind a number of questions that I considered very serious, which completely shook my world and threatened tremendous possible ramifications for my faith as a Christian. A series of unexpected sources of inspiration, confusion, and clarity took me on a journey filled with numerous difficult questions, considerable doubt, ample inaction, and far too much wasted time. I questioned Christianity at a level more basic than I had ever before thought that I would, and as my old roommate Dave recently said to me, “I tell you, if you’ve never had to question even the most basic tenets of Christianity, it can be brutal. Really brutal.” Dave was unequivocally correct.

Read the rest…

October 11, 2009 · Comment

A few years back, I helped start a website called Epinoia Cafe. It was many things, I’m sure, but from my perspective at least, it was me and several friends exploring the new (at the time) Emergent Church movement, in a common forum. But as those who were in on it from the beginning may have noticed, I haven’t written a word at Epinoia Café in a very long time. And I’ll be honest with you: I haven’t really stopped by to read, either.

The other day, I was thinking about why that is. After all, I helped Josh Kagi and Anthony Doheny start the thing; it wasn’t my idea, but I was in on the brainstorming, and at one point, I was very excited about it. Early on, I both wrote and responded frequently. But as far as I can tell by browsing through the archives, that lasted but a few months, dwindling off sometime around February of 2007.

What happened to me?

Read the rest…

August 1, 2009 · 19 comments